November 30, 2004

WERE YOU TALKING TO ME? . . . Mario Cuomo refers to "shopworn rhetorical labels" of liberal and conservative in his Why Lincoln Matters: Today More than Ever (Harcourt). It’s reviewed in Claremont Review, Fall ‘04, where it is called a book of "comic failures" for its bending of Lincoln to liberal Dem purposes.

Kerry spoke of "tired labels" in a debate after Bush cited his liberal voting record, of which he seemed not proud.

Liberal pols are more often on the defensive about their liberalism than conservatives are about their conservatism – Bush flaunted his and that was a winning strategy – which is why "ultra" and "far right" (never far left) have such appeal to mainstream media (MSM) reporters and editors.

For instance, Chi Trib’s Charles Madigan uses a blog column to deny the difference. He may see it that way, but it’s a tack taken by libs trying to shed unpopularity.

LA BELLE NOTHING . . . Alfred Hitchock’s two French-language war-effort (propaganda) films, "Bon Voyage" and "Aventure Malgache," were suppressed by the British government as "inflammatory," apparently because they featured Vichy-French pro-German treachery. Both were made in England, 1944, in black and white, were released on video by the British Film Institute in 1993. The video is at OPPL, which stocks a number of films unavailable elsewhere in the vicinity – but should try stacking them as they stack books, by genre.

The suppression of these films exemplifies the French problem, rather, the problem of what to do with them. Vichy, headed by WW1 hero Petain and Laval, was enthusiastically fascist and anti-semitic. It shipped thousands of Jews to camps. The SS "Charlemagne" Division consisted of French soldiers who died defending Hitler. (There was a Dutch equivalent, also SS.) There was very little French resistance during war. The French liked Vichy. Fascism was popular.

Meanwhile, DeGaulle was a big problem for the Allies, demanding this and that and being unwilling to condemn the deadly resistance by Vichy French to U.S. troops invading N. Africa. Read Miller & Molesky’s excellent Our Oldest Enemy: A History of America's Disastrous Relationship with France.

SECOND THOUGHTS . . . Newspaper retractions, or skinbacks, are worth reading. It’s the first thing radio talker Teri O’Brien, recent replacement for Don & Roma on WLS, reads in NY Times. Chi Trib skinbacks for 11/2/04:

* Two green radical groups are not "formally linked" with a play about which they were interviewed. (The play’s producers wanted to make that clear, probably lest they get tarred with radicalism when all they want is to be artistic and make a few bucks.

* CBS’s "60 Minutes" producer had nothing to do with the botched Bush-Texas Air Natl Guard (TANG) story. It was "60 Minutes-Wednesday." (Don’t blame us.)

* The Oklahoma quarterback threw four TD passes, not four interceptions in Saturday’s victory. (Oh. His mother thanks you profusely.)

DRINKING OUT . . . The new Caribou at OP & Lake is very good. On a recent week day morning, I was greeted nicely, given a china cup as a stay-there drinker (was later offered a refill!). Regular (refillable) was $1.52. Sat at window table. It wobbled a little, but gave me a view of Sco Park across street kitty-corner. Pleasant clientele came and went with coffee for Green Line ride downtown. The two serving guys were chatty and not annoying. Piped music was not too loud. There was bustle not chaos. All in all, a nice place. Sat there a good 45 minutes reading and note-taking. Old Oak Parker Henry P. spotted me, made faces in window. Good, good spot.

FOR YOUR CREATIVE MISREADING COLLECTION . . . "Non-plussed" means confused, not unimpressed or unfazed, as Wed Jnl writer Bill Dwyer used it 10/26/04, in a story headed "Sparks fly as Davis debates Davis-Fairman," about candidates for U.S. Congress.

BIG COUNTRY, FUNNY GUY . . . Canada has more geography than history, quipped Mackenzie King, its prime mininster 1921-30 and 1935-48.

LITTLE MONEY, FUNNY GUY . . . A free-lance writer, said Robert Benchley, is "a man who is paid per piece or per word or perhaps."
– From Michael J. Rosen, ed., Thurber Collecting Himself: on Writing and Writers, Humor, and Himself.

November 25, 2004

Anti-Christians one, Christians nothing in Brussels, with a chance the game isn't over till it's over.

">Link


November 11, 2004

If Irish, if Catholic, then what?

SWEARING IN . . . The installation of the new St. Edmund’s pastor on Oct. 24 was a thing of beauty and a joy for all concerned. Bishop Thomas Paprocki preached, reading at length from a recent statement in which the Pope emphasized holiness – which came as no surprise to many but was still O.K. to say.

After everyone recited the Creed, the new pastor, Fr. John McGivern, recited a special pledge of his own as pastor, about which more later. Then in a sort of welcoming ceremony, the parish’s non-priest staff and parish pastoral council members came one after the other to deliver brief hugs. One mature woman planted a motherly kiss on his cheek. (Ordained in 1991 and so probably under 40, he looks no older.)

Ushers brought empty collection baskets as part of the ceremony – to be filled later, noted the bishop, ad-libbing nicely.

The people were asked to accept Fr. John as pastor: “We will,” they said. All extended hands in blessing him, then applauded, and church bells rang.

The baskets were passed and filled as the song leader led. She looked out at the congregation, of course, as did the priests. There were two others besides Fr. McG and the bishop. Indeed, Fr. McG at one point, apparently catching the eye of a friend, grinned briefly, then caught himself.

Mass over, he thanked everyone. In four months, he had found the church “beautiful,” ditto the people. He noted that his mother and the bishop’s mother, members of the same Evergreen Park parish, know each other and chat now and then, turning and admonishing the bishop, “So let’s both be careful.”

He had earlier been careful to say the new-pastor’s pledge of allegiance, which included his intention to go along with what bishops say as a group even when they are not pronouncing doctrine. “Religious submission of will and intellect” is what he promised.

SWEARING OFF . . . Meanwhile, at Ascension Church a mile away, the pastor, Fr. Larry McNally, was rejecting U.S. bishops’ instructions to make pro-life issues a voter’s prime concern – something the bishops had done by classing abortion and euthanasia as “preeminent threats to human life and dignity.” Chicago’s Cardinal Francis George had also put his own oar in, calling “the defense of every human life . . . not just one of a laundry list of moral concerns” but “key to pursuing the common good.” Indeed, Cardinal George has said he refrains from refusing communion to pro-choice politicos “primarily because . . . it would turn the reception of Holy Communion into a circus.”

Fr. McNally, on the other hand, rejected ‘one issue” voting and called heretical those (unnamed) bishops who say it’s a sin not only to be but also to vote for pro-choice candidates. He also impugned bishops’ authority in general because they “looked the other way while some . . . priests hurt so many little children.”

It was courage and integrity on display, said this newspaper, though in today’s climate it’s doubtful much will come of it. Won’t it be something, on the other hand, when a pastor at his installation refuses to make his promise of “religious submission” in the first place?

As for Ascension parishioners, some had been instructed in voting their consciences by loop lawyer John J. Gearen at a mid-October Adult Formation meeting – which unfortunately was a version of asking a Chevy or Toyota dealer what car to buy. Gearen was to provide “a well formed and informed Catholic perspective,” according to the parish bulletin, but he already had given $3,000 to Kerry, as reported in this newspaper. His wife Ann gave another $4,000, which made them Oak Park’s family with the mostest for the (pro-choice) man from Massachusetts. Gearen also is finance chairman for state’s attorney Dick Devine, a Democrat.

This with other evidence too extensive to mention has led me to compose the following lyric, sung to the popular pre-K tune, “If you’re happy and you know it, clap your hands”:

If you’re Irish and you’re Catholic, you’re a Dem,
If you’re Irish and you’re Catholic, you’re a Dem,
If you’re Irish and you’re Catholic, then you sure as heaven know it,
And no bishop has to tell you how to vote.

Amen!


[Wed. Journal of Oak Park & River Forest, 11/10/04]